Choosing between a backpack or suitcase is one of the first decisions you’ll have to make in planning a trip. Both come with their pros and cons, and your travel style, as well aswhat destination or activity you are doing will determine which to choose. And here’s a side-by-side comparison to see which one is right for you
Flexibility and Mobility
The most important benefit of a backpack is its portability. Backpack = freedom of movement, especially in destination cities where walking or public transportation is the go-to. If you’re going to be making your way through narrow streets, hiking to a distant village, or getting on and off buses, a backpack gives you so much more flexibility and ease to get where you need to go. A lot of backpackers like the flexibility that comes with not having to roll their bags or wait on elevators in busy areas.
However, a suitcase — especially a larger one — can quickly become unwieldy in places where roads are bumpy—or sidewalks are congested. On the other hand, wheeled luggage is made for smooth surfaces, i.e. airports and city streets, and can be easier to handle in an urban setting where mobility might not be as big of a deal.
Storage Space and Packing Capacity
Suitcases generally have more room than backpacks and use clever internal organization to help you break things down into compartments for clothing, toiletries, and other items. For those who like to keep their bag nice and orderly, suitcases with compartments and dividers inside are perfect. Suitcases also allow for larger and heavier packing so they are preferred for longer journeys where more gear is needed.
Conversely, backpacks are typically more condensed and although a lot of contemporary backpacks come with multiple compartments, they provide less room for organization overall compared to a suitcase. Nonetheless, they offer some room to grow, particularly if you choose a large, multi-compartment travel backpack. Backpacks do need a bit of creative packing to keep everything organized, though — but they do hold all the different types of gear you might want to carry with you, making them more flexible.
Comfort and Convenience
Key factor should be the comfort to carry your luggage. Backpacks distribute weight evenly across your body, making them comfortable for long hikes or navigating uneven terrain. Adjustable straps and ergonomic designs minimize back strain, making backpacks ideal for harsh destinations and hands-free convenience.
Suitcases, on the other hand, are easier to manage over short distances, especially on smooth surfaces. Wheels make pulling a suitcase easier than carrying, especially when walking in airports, train stations, or smooth pavement. A suitcase is cumbersome for long distances and rough terrain, as it’s difficult to lift and maneuver.
Durability
When comparing a backpack to a suitcase, durability is a second factor to consider. Travel backpacks, especially for hiking, use durable, weather-resistant materials that resist rips and tears. Additionally, these crafts often have better durability, which is especially important in remote locations.
Suitcases, though heavy and built for air travel, can be damaged by rough handling or extreme conditions. Dropping suitcases or using them in tough environments may cause the outer shell to crack and wheels to wear out.
Security
As far as security is concerned, both backpacks and suitcases have an option for keeping your things safe. Lockable zippers, hidden compartments, and anti-theft features on backpacks provide essential security, especially in high-risk areas. Hard-shell suitcases can be fitted with locks like you would regularly see with a regular suitcase and offer a little better protection for fragile items.)
But with a backpack you have instant access to things and to keep your valuables on your person. A large suitcase can be slower to access and harder to keep close in crowded areas.
Conclusion
Choosing between a backpack or suitcase comes down to the preference of your travel style, destination, and trip type. If you plan to go to the city or a luxury getaway, however, a suitcase may suit you best feeling most convenient and organized. For activities like hiking or traveling between locations, a backpack is more convenient and practical than a suitcase.
Taking into account mobility, capacity, comfort, and durability will help you decide what is best for your travels!
