America had always been the land of complete tastes where food trends changed just about as fast as fashion fads. But some snacks, despite the fact that everybody loved them, found themselves on the wrong side of the law and simply disappeared from store shelves due to various regulatory or health concerns. The history of America’s banned snacks is intriguing, often a laced battle that ebbs and flows between debates on public health, consumer freedom, and the role of government oversight in the details of our daily lives. Let’s take a tour through some of the most famous, or infamous, snacks that were once loved but are now forbidden fruit.
-
Kinder Surprise Eggs: A Sweet with a Surprise Ban
One of the most recognized banned snacks in America is that of the Kinder Surprise Egg. This chocolate egg, with its inside toy, has been such a staple of European countries for decades. In the United States, though, it has been banned since the 1930s due to a law against selling any food that contains an embedded non-nutritive object on its center. A fear that the little toy inside the egg presents a choking hazard, particularly to young children. Its popularity abroad notwithstanding, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has kept it banned, making Kinder Surprise Eggs highly coveted contraband for candy enthusiasts who smuggle them into the country.
-
Four Loko: The Caffeinated Alcohol Controversy
It gained popularity in the late 2000s among college students and young adults: Four Loko is basically a pre-mixed, caffeinated alcoholic beverage. The potent mix of alcohol and caffeine had been being marketed to keep the party going sans crash. It wasn’t long before reports of dangerous intoxication levels, hospitalizations, and even deaths began to surface. In 2010, the FDA issued warning letters to the manufacturers of Four Loko and similar drinks, citing caffeine mixed with alcohol as an “unsafe food additive.” A national ban was then placed on the original formula of Four Loko. Today, the beverage is still manufactured and sold in stores sans the caffeine that made it infamous.
-
Haggis: A Traditional Dish with a Federal Ban
Although not, per se, a snack, haggis is the traditional Scottish dish made of sheep’s organs mixed with oatmeal and spices deserves a respect mention for its peculiar status of one of handful of banned foods in America. Due to one of its main ingredient, sheep lungs, the USDA has banned the importation of haggis since 1971. According to the USDA it is unfit for human consumption. Despite the ban, haggis is a favorite delicacy in Scotland, and fans across the U.S. have attempted making it with various ingredients substituted.
-
Marmite: Love It or Hate It
Marmite is one of the many British yeast extract spreads to face restrictions in the United States. While not exactly illegal, Marmite has been the object of import bans instituted by the United States on account of its high folic acid content. In 2011, word spread that the FDA had banned Marmite, along with other imported foods enhanced with folic acid, due to concerns over too much of the vitamin. As it happens, Marmite lovers can still locate the spread in specialty stores, it’s less commonly found than it happens to be in the UK.
-
Artificially Colored Snacks: A Battle Over Food Dyes
Artificial colouring for foods has been a debatable issue in America for the last decades. Most dyes, actually, have been banned as some are linked to cancers in laboratory animals, one of which is Red No. 3. Therefore, many of those candies or snacks with bright colors have either changed formula or pulled out of the market. For example, the blue M&M classic was banned temporarily in the U.S. in the 1970s after studies raised red flags about the safety of its dye, until it was later reintroduced using a different coloring agent. The debate over artificial food coloring has continued, with some consumers calling for more natural alternatives.
-
Sassafras: The Root Beer Flavoring with a Dangerous Twist
Sassafras has long been a popular ingredient in root beer, giving that special flavor to the drink. In the 1960s, though, the FDA banned sassafras oil because studies indicated one of the chemicals it contained, called safrole, could damage livers and cause cancer in laboratory animals. Fans of root beer are free to enjoy the beverage, but today it must be made with either artificial flavorings or with safrole-free sassafras extract so as not to violate the ban set by the FDA. The ban on sassafras reveals a modern conflict between sustaining traditional flavors and the safety of the public.
Conclusion
Snack bans in America mostly emerged through what became almost a delicate balance dance among public health concerns, consumer choices, and regulatory actions. While there are valid reasons for some of these bans due to food safety concerns, debates over freedom of personal choices have usually been associated with them. Whether it’s the colorful allure of a Kinder Surprise Egg or the bold taste of a Marmite sandwich, such banned snacks remind us that what we eat can sometimes be more a matter of law than taste. As regulations evolve and new food trends come forward, it will be interesting to see what snacks will make a comeback-or disappear forever-from American shelves.
